PT16.5.1 · Art & Architecture

Classical Music of India
Hindustani & Carnatic Traditions — Origins, Raga, Tala & Exponents

📖 UPSC Prelims GS-I 🎵 Art & Culture ⭐ High Yield
Section 01 · Foundations

Ancient Foundations of Indian Classical Music

Indian classical music has its deepest roots in the Samaveda (c. 1500–1200 BCE) — the Veda of melody, which consists largely of Rigvedic hymns set to musical chant (saman). The study of Samaveda is the oldest recorded musical tradition in the world. The concept of the saptak (the seven notes of the octave — sa, re, ga, ma, pa, dha, ni — corresponding to the Western do-re-mi) was formulated in ancient India and remains the foundation of both Hindustani and Carnatic music today.

The first systematic theoretical treatment of music appears in the Natyashastra of Bharata Muni (c. 200 BCE – 200 CE), which devotes several chapters to musical scales (gramas), notes (svaras), modes (jatis), and melodic forms. Later treatises developed the raga system: the Sangita Ratnakara of Sarngadeva (13th century CE, Yadava court in Devagiri) is the last major Indian musicological text considered authoritative by both Hindustani and Carnatic traditions — it was composed just before the split between the two schools began.

The central concept of Indian classical music is the raga — a melodic framework defined by: a specific set of notes (svaras), a characteristic ascending (arohana) and descending (avarohana) pattern, characteristic ornaments (gamaks, meends), a characteristic note (vadi — most important, and samvadi — second most important), a time of day or season when it is traditionally performed, and an associated mood (rasa). A raga is not a scale or a tune — it is a unique melodic personality.

⚠ EXAMINER TRAP — Raga vs Scale: A raga is NOT merely a scale. Two ragas can use the same notes but differ in their characteristic phrases, the emphasis on certain notes, ornaments, and the ascending/descending patterns. For example, Ragas Bhairav and Bilaskhani Todi may use similar notes but are completely different in character.
Section 02 · The Split

The Hindustani-Carnatic Split (13th–16th Century)

The divergence of Indian classical music into the northern (Hindustani) and southern (Carnatic) traditions is one of the most significant events in the history of Indian culture. The split was NOT an abrupt event but a gradual process spanning roughly 300 years (13th–16th century).

The primary cause was the Persian and Central Asian cultural influence on North India following the establishment of the Delhi Sultanate (1206) and later the Mughal Empire. The key figure in this synthesis was Amir Khusrau (1253–1325), poet, musician, and Sufi disciple of Nizamuddin Auliya. Khusrau is credited with inventing (or developing) several instruments (sitar, tabla — though historians debate this) and composing in mixed Persian-Hindi registers (khayal, tarana, qawwali). He worked at the courts of several Delhi Sultans.

South India, under the Vijayanagara Empire (14th–17th century), remained insulated from these influences. The Vijayanagara courts patronised pure Sanskrit-Tamil-Telugu music scholarship. Purandaradasa (c. 1484–1564), a Vaishnava devotee from Karnataka, is considered the "father of Carnatic music" — he systematised the teaching of Carnatic music by composing graded exercises (svaravalis, alankaras, gitas) still used today as the curriculum for Carnatic music students. The Sangeet Natak Akademi's classification and the general consensus places the final consolidation of the two traditions around the 16th century.

⚠ EXAMINER TRAP — Amir Khusrau and Instruments: Amir Khusrau is traditionally credited with inventing the sitar and tabla. However, historians debate this — the sitar is believed to have evolved over a longer period from the Persian setar and Indian been/vina traditions. Similarly, the tabla likely evolved from earlier percussion instruments. UPSC questions may ask about the traditional attribution, so know: Khusrau is traditionally credited; the actual history is more complex.
Section 03 · Hindustani Tradition

Hindustani Classical Music

Hindustani classical music is the dominant classical tradition of North India, Pakistan, Nepal, and parts of Bangladesh. It is characterised by extensive improvisation — a performance can last hours as the musician elaborates the chosen raga through a structured sequence from slow to fast, with the accompanying rhythm instrument (tabla or pakhawaj) entering progressively. The same raga can be presented in countless ways by different musicians.

Principal Vocal Forms

Dhrupad is the oldest surviving classical vocal form — austere, serious, meditative, in four parts (sthayi, antara, sanchari, abhog). It was the dominant court music of the Mughal period. The Dagar tradition and Dagarvani are famous dhrupad lineages. Khayal ("imagination" in Persian/Urdu) gradually replaced dhrupad as the dominant form from the 18th century onward — it allows for more emotional freedom and ornamental elaboration. Most modern Hindustani vocalists perform khayal. Thumri is a lighter, more romantic form closely associated with the devotional poetry of Radha-Krishna and with dance. Tappa originates in the folk songs of Punjab camel drivers; Dadra and Ghazal are semi-classical/light forms.

Gharanas and Key Exponents

Major Hindustani vocal gharanas include: Gwalior (oldest; Nathan Pir Baksh founded it in the early 19th century; Vishnu Digambar Paluskar was associated with popularising Hindustani music for the masses through public concerts); Kirana (Abdul Karim Khan; lyrical pure raga exposition; Gangubai Hangal, Bhimsen Joshi were associated with this style); Agra; Jaipur-Atrauli (Alladiya Khan; known for rare ragas and complex treatment). Instrument-based gharanas also exist: the Maihar gharana of sitar/sarod playing (Allauddin Khan, teacher of Ravi Shankar and Ali Akbar Khan).

Greatest 20th-century Hindustani musicians: Pandit Ravi Shankar (sitar; brought Indian music to the world; Grammy winner; Bharat Ratna 1999); Bismillah Khan (shehnai; Bharat Ratna 2001); Pandit Bhimsen Joshi (vocalist, Kirana gharana; Bharat Ratna 2008); M.S. Subbulakshmi (Carnatic, but first musician to receive Bharat Ratna 1998); Ustad Zakir Hussain (tabla).

MEMORY AID — Bharat Ratna Musicians: M.S. Subbulakshmi (1998) was the FIRST musician to receive Bharat Ratna. Then: Ravi Shankar (1999), Bismillah Khan (2001), Bhimsen Joshi (2008), Lata Mangeshkar (2001), Zakir Hussain (posthumous, 2025). Note: Subbulakshmi was Carnatic, not Hindustani.
Section 04 · Carnatic Tradition

Carnatic Classical Music

Carnatic music is the classical tradition of South India — Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Kerala, and Andhra Pradesh/Telangana. Compared to Hindustani music, Carnatic music is more composition-based — the bulk of performance time is devoted to rendering pre-composed pieces (krithis) with improvisational elaboration interwoven. The improvisation forms (raga alapana, neraval, kalpanaswara) are present but the compositions carry greater structural weight than in Hindustani khayal.

The Trinity of Carnatic Music

The canonical repertoire of Carnatic music is dominated by three composers of the late 18th–early 19th century, collectively called the Carnatic Trinity: Tyagaraja (1767–1847) of Thiruvaiyaru, Tamil Nadu — the most prolific and beloved, composing nearly 700 surviving krithis in Telugu, primarily devoted to Lord Rama. His Pancharatna Krithis (five gems) are performed at Thyagaraja Aradhana festivals every year. Muthuswami Dikshitar (1775–1835) — composed 479 krithis mostly in Sanskrit; visited North India and incorporated some Hindustani elements. Syama Sastri (1762–1827) — composed in Telugu; known for his kritis to Bangaru Kamakshi (Goddess Parvati) at Thanjavur.

Purandaradasa — Father of Carnatic Music

Purandaradasa (c. 1484–1564, Karnataka) is called the Karnataka Sangeeta Pitamaha ("grandfather of Karnataka music") — he created the systematic pedagogical framework of Carnatic music still in use today. He composed ~475,000 compositions (tradition claims), of which about 1,000 survive. His Mayamalavagowla is the first raga taught to Carnatic students.

⚠ EXAMINER TRAP — Carnatic Trinity Members and Languages: Tyagaraja = Telugu; Dikshitar = Sanskrit (primarily); Syama Sastri = Telugu. All three lived contemporaneously in the Thanjavur-Tiruvarur region of Tamil Nadu. They are NOT considered "founders" of Carnatic music — Purandaradasa (16th century Karnataka) is the systematiser/founder.
Section 05 · Instruments

Classical Musical Instruments

Indian musical instruments are classified by the Natyashastra into four categories (chaturvidha vadya): Tata (stringed — plucked or bowed), Sushira (wind/blown), Avanaddha (membrane/skin-covered percussion), Ghana (solid percussion — idiophones). This classification is also used by Hornbostel-Sachs internationally as Chordophone, Aerophone, Membranophone, and Idiophone.

CategoryHindustani InstrumentsCarnatic Instruments
Tata (Plucked)Sitar, Sarod, Been/Rudra Veena, Saraswati Veena, TanpuraVeena (Saraswati Veena), Gottuvadyam, Tanpura
Tata (Bowed)Sarangi, EsrajViolin (Western instrument adopted extensively in Carnatic)
Sushira (Wind)Shehnai (Bismillah Khan), Bansuri (flute)Flute (Carnatic/bamboo), Nadaswaram (nagaswaram — temple instrument)
Avanaddha (Percussion)Tabla (pair; right = tabla, left = bayan), PakhawajMridangam (barrel drum; main Carnatic percussion), Ghatam (clay pot), Kanjira (frame drum)
⚠ EXAMINER TRAP — Violin in Carnatic Music: The violin is NOT an Indian instrument by origin — it was introduced by Europeans. However, it was adopted into Carnatic classical music in the early 19th century and is now one of the primary instruments in Carnatic performance (used as both solo instrument and accompaniment). The Western violin is played in a seated position holding it between the foot and shoulder in Carnatic style — different from Western bowing technique.
Section 06 · Comparison

Hindustani vs Carnatic: Key Differences

FeatureHindustaniCarnatic
RegionNorth India, Pakistan, NepalSouth India (TN, Karnataka, AP, Kerala)
Persian InfluenceSignificant (khayal, ghazal, tabla, sitar)None — developed independently
ApproachImprovisation dominant; compositions are skeletons for improvisationComposition dominant; improvisation interwoven
Vocal formsDhrupad (oldest), Khayal (dominant), Thumri, Tappa, GhazalKrithi (dominant), Varnam, Padam, Javali, Tillana
Raga concept~500+ ragas; time theory strictly followed; 10 parent scales (thaats)72 parent scales (mela scheme); time theory less rigidly followed
Main percussionTablaMridangam
DroneTanpuraTanpura or shruti box
Key theoristVishnu Narayan Bhatkhande (standardised 10 thaats in 20th c.)Venkatamakhi (72 mela scheme, 17th c.)
TrinityNo equivalent (but Gwalior, Kirana gharanas are formative)Tyagaraja, Dikshitar, Syama Sastri (18th–19th c.)
Father figureAmir Khusrau (13th c.) for synthesis; Bhatkhande for modern systematisationPurandaradasa (16th c.)
Section 07 · PYQ Practice

Previous Year Questions

UPSC Prelims 2017
With reference to the 'Dhrupad' in Indian classical music, which of the following statements is/are correct?
1. Dhrupad originated and developed in the Mughal period by the Mughal kings.
2. Dhrupad is primarily a devotional and spiritual music.
3. Dhrupad has been heavily influenced by Persian music and adapted accordingly.
(a) 1 and 2 only   (b) 2 only   (c) 1, 2 and 3   (d) 2 and 3 only

Answer: (b) 2 only
Statement 1 is wrong: Dhrupad predates the Mughal period — it developed in the Gwalior Sultanate under Man Singh Tomar (15th century) and was patronised by Raja Man Singh, not invented by the Mughals. Statement 2 is correct: Dhrupad is a devotional and spiritual form, usually in praise of deities or kings. Statement 3 is wrong: Dhrupad was largely insulated from Persian influence — it is regarded as the most "pure" Indian classical form; it was Khayal that absorbed more Persian elements.
UPSC Prelims 2018 (adapted)
Consider the following pairs (Musician : Instrument):
1. Bismillah Khan : Sarangi
2. Zakir Hussain : Tabla
3. Ravi Shankar : Sarod
4. Hariprasad Chaurasia : Bansuri (flute)
How many pairs are correctly matched?
(a) One   (b) Two   (c) Three   (d) Four

Answer: (b) Two (pairs 2 and 4)
Bismillah Khan = shehnai (NOT sarangi; sarangi was played by Pandit Ram Narayan). Ravi Shankar = sitar (NOT sarod; sarod = Ali Akbar Khan, Amjad Ali Khan). Zakir Hussain = tabla (correct). Hariprasad Chaurasia = bansuri/flute (correct).
Section 08 · FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the 'Thaats' system in Hindustani music and who systematised it?
The thaat (also spelled "that") system is the parent-scale classification system for Hindustani ragas, systematised by the musicologist Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande (1860–1936) in the early 20th century. Bhatkhande organised the hundreds of Hindustani ragas into 10 parent scales (thaats): Kalyan, Bilawal, Khamaj, Bhairav, Poorvi, Marwa, Kafi, Asavari, Bhairavi, and Todi. Every Hindustani raga is derived from one of these 10 thaats. Bhatkhande also standardised notation and wrote extensively on Hindustani music theory. His work was crucial in institutionalising Hindustani music in music schools (notably the Marris College of Music, Lucknow — now Bhatkhande Sangeet Sansthan). The parallel figure in Carnatic music was Venkatamakhi (17th century), who created the 72-mela (parent scale) system.
What is the 'Sangeet Natak Akademi' and what does it do?
The Sangeet Natak Akademi (SNA) is India's national academy of music, dance, and drama, established in 1952 by the Government of India. It is the apex body for the performing arts in India. Key functions: (1) Classifies and recognises classical performing art forms (currently 8 classical dances, 2 classical music traditions); (2) Awards the Sangeet Natak Akademi Award (Akademi Award) — the highest honour in India's performing arts — and the Sangeet Natak Akademi Fellowship (the highest honour given to living legends); (3) Maintains archives; promotes research; organises festivals; supports training institutions. The SNA is chaired by a Chairman (a distinguished arts personality) and is distinct from the Ministry of Culture, though funded by it. It is NOT a Ministry or Department — it is an autonomous body under the Ministry of Culture.
What is Qawwali and how does it relate to Indian classical music?
Qawwali is a form of Sufi devotional music that originated in the Sufi hospices (khanqahs) of South Asia, particularly associated with the Chishti order. It is not technically a "classical" form but shares roots with Hindustani music. Key features: performed by a lead singer (qawwal) with chorus and instruments; text is primarily in Persian, Urdu, or Punjabi; the purpose is to induce spiritual ecstasy (wajd) in listeners. The most famous modern exponent was Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan (Pakistan). In India, qawwali is associated with the Dargah tradition — especially at the dargah of Nizamuddin Auliya in Delhi, where the tradition has continued since the 13th century (the time of Amir Khusrau). Qawwali contributed some musical elements and the khayal-ghazal synthesis to Hindustani music.
What is the 'Thyagaraja Aradhana' festival and where is it held?
The Thyagaraja Aradhana is the most important annual festival of Carnatic classical music, held at Thiruvaiyaru (Thanjavur district, Tamil Nadu) — the birthplace and final resting place of the composer Tyagaraja (1767–1847). The festival takes place on the Pushya bahula panchami day (January–February each year, which corresponds to the anniversary of Tyagaraja's death). Hundreds of Carnatic musicians from across India and the world gather to perform Tyagaraja's compositions — especially the Pancharatna Krithis (five gems) — in a grand unison performance that begins the festival. The Aradhana is a unique event where classical music is performed as mass communal worship. A parallel Aradhana is also held in Cleveland, USA — the world's largest annual gathering of Carnatic musicians outside India.